Most of them are quite forgettable – It’s what the star of Mentality Hunter said about most of the programs on television at this time, and he is not wrong. Most shows not called Mentality Hunter are quite forgettable, which is just another reason why their cancellation was an annoyance. David Fincher’s filmography is up to par with some of the best modern directors, and his streak of success puts him in contention on the long list of best directors in history. Even if you find the macabre and horrifying little appetizing, you can’t deny the art and strength of his narration.
Rarely do directors of Fincher’s caliber come down from Mount Hollywood to work as a television showrunner, so when they do, it’s worth paying attention. Fincher rewarded loyal viewers with two seasons of the best show of the last 15 years. Mentality Hunter is based on the 1995 true crime book Mindhunter: Inside the FBI Elite Serial Crime Unit, which tracks the FBI’s Behavioral Sciences Unit foundation, and how they interviewed and imprisoned notorious serial murderers. A fantastic series, Mentality Hunter was canceled after two brief seasons.
The Star Holt McCallany Believes that Mindhunter Was Not Forgettable Like Most Shows
McCallany Respects David Fincher, But Would Have Loved for the Show to Continue
After Mentality Hunter was canceled in early 2020, Holt McCallany, who plays Special Agent Bill Tench, had some things to say about the series. McCallany expressed strong feelings about his time in Mentality Hunter and considered it an important experience in his career. The series currently holds a 97% rating on Rotten Tomatoes and was nominated for two Emmy Awards. It was a critical success and possibly one of the best projects McCallany has been a part of. It’s understandable that he misses the time spent with the series.
Mindhunter Was One of the Best Crime Programs on Television, and Was Still Canceled
Mindhunter Serves as an Explanation for Any Program or Film Involving a Serial Killer
Mentality Hunter was one of the best and most unique crime programs on television during its airing, and few crime series that came before it were comparable. While there’s nothing particularly novel about a crime show featuring detectives or FBI agents pursuing serial killers, what Mentality Hunter does is marry that classic genre with the infinitely fascinating and true history of how the FBI came to understand the behavior and psychology behind these mass murderers. What Bill and Holden discover about serial killers forms the basis of our understanding of the psychology behind murder.
There Hasn’t Been a Show Like Mindhunter Since the David Fincher Series Ended
Fincher Explored Killers to an Extent That Other Shows Are Unwilling To
That doesn’t mean everything they did or determined was correct, but their approach to looking at murderers from a different perspective beyond just finding clues at a crime scene not only laid the foundation for criminal psychology and criminal profiling but also helps explain numerous plots of serial killers in TV shows and movies. It’s like the prequel to every SVU episode or Shout movie. Moreover, Mentality Hunter presents a fantastic style and the economic, tense direction, and storytelling.
David Fincher Decided to Follow Other Projects, Leading to the Cancellation of Mindhunter
It’s the perfect fit for a show like this, where the process is vital. Watching detectives and scientists try to write the book on criminal psychology could have been mundane, but thanks to Fincher, every piece of information shines, every vague connection made, and every disturbing historical fact discovered feels more gripping than any run-of-the-mill police procedural show.
